openafs/CODING

Notes on Coding Standards/Requirements for OpenAFS Source
---------------------------------------------------------

We have an official style.  Please use it.  If you have gnu indent 2.2.9 or
later you can reformat for this style with the following option:

-npro -nbad -bap -nbc -bbo -br -ce -cdw -brs -ncdb -cp1 -ncs -di2 -ndj -nfc1
-nfca -i4 -lp -npcs -nprs -psl -sc -nsob -ts8

Do not use $< for non-pattern rules in any cross-platform dir as it
requires a reasonable make that is not available on all systems.

Do not have build rules that build multiple targets. Make doesn't seem able
to handle this, and it interferes with -j builds. (In particular, build the
rxgen targets individually and not using the flags for building all the files
in one shot.)

Try to test builds using gmake -j # MAKE="gmake -j #", it seems like a good
way to find missing or order-dependent dependency rules. (Is there a better
way to do this?)

-- Prototyping and Style --
Prototypes for all source files in a given dir DDD should be placed
in the file DDD/DDD_prototypes.h. All externally used (either API
or used by other source files) routines and variables should be
prototyped in this file.

The prototypes should be a full prototype, with argument and return
types. (Should not generate a warning with gcc -Wstrict-prototypes.)

Format of the prototype files should look like:

	Standard Copyright Notice

	#ifndef AFS_SRC_DDD_PROTO_H
	#define AFS_SRC_DDD_PROTO_H

	/* filename.c */
	prototypes

	/* filename.c */
	prototypes

	#endif /* AFS_SRC_DDD_PROTO_H */

In most of the existing prototypes, the define is DDD_PROTOTYPES_H, which is
probably ok as well.

The declaration of the routines should be done in ANSI style. If at some
later date, it is determined that prototypes don't work on some platform
properly, we can use ansi2knr during the compile.

	rettype
	routine(argtype arg)
	{

	}

All routines should have a return type specified, void if nothing returned,
and should have (void) if no arguments are taken.

Header files should not contain macros or other definitions unless they
are used across multiple source files.

All routines should be declared static if they are not used outside that
source file.

Compiles on gcc-using machines should strive to handle using
-Wstrict-prototypes -Werror. (this may take a while)

Routines shall be defined in source prior to use if possible, and
prototyped in block at top of file if static.

API documentation in the code should be done using Qt-style Doxygen
comments.

If you make a routine or variable static, be sure and remove it from
the AIX .exp files.

Suggested compiler flags:
	gcc: -Wall -Wstrict-prototypes
	Solaris Workshop CC: -fd -v
		(You might not want the -fd, it isn't really useful, just complains about the
		K&R style functions, but -v gives useful info.)

Multiple line comment blocks should begin with only /* on one line and end with
only */ on one line.

Example:

	/*
	 * Multiple line comment blocks should be formatted
	 * like this example.
	 */

Do not use braces on one-line if and loop statements.

Use:

	if (some_condition)
	    do_some_action();
	else
	    do_something_else();

	while (some_condition)
	    do_something();

Instead of:

	if (some_condition) {
	    do_some_action();
	}

	while (some_condition) {
	    do_something();
	}


Dependencies required to build OpenAFS from source
--------------------------------------------------
The following packages are required to build all of the OpenAFS code
from source on various operating systems:

On Debian:
- autoconf, automake, bison, comerr-dev, cpio, flex, libkrb5-dev,
  libncurses5-dev, libpam0g-dev, libxml2-utils, perl, pkg-config;
- libfuse-dev (for the FUSE-based user-mode client);
- dblatex, docbook-xsl, doxygen, xsltproc (for documentation);
- debhelper, hardening-wrapper, dkms (to build the Debian packages)

On FreeBSD:
- autoconf, automake, libtool;
- fusefs-libs, pkgconf (for the FUSE-based user-mode client);
- perl, dblatex, docbook-xsl, libxslt, python, ruby, zip (for documentation)

In addition, FreeBSD systems require kernel sources and a configured kernel
build directory (see section "FreeBSD Notes" in the README file).

GIT Usage
=========

*WARNING* *WARNING* *WARNING* *WARNING* *WARNING* *WARNING* *WARNING*
The Git tree may not always have code which can currently be built.
While every effort is made to keep the head of the tree buildable,
you may at any time find yourself between commits and hence have a tree
which does not build, or worse, causes more serious problems!

Do not use the Git tree unless you know what you're doing.

Git checkouts do not include files generated by autoconf. You can
run regen.sh (at the top level) to create these files. You will need
to have autoconf and automake installed on your system.

Summary
-------

Browse:  http://git.openafs.org/
Clone:   git clone git://git.openafs.org/openafs.git

Step-by-step
------------

1. Obtain the Git software. If you are using a system with a standard
   software repository, Git may already be available as a package named
   something like git or git-core.  Otherwise, go to http://git-scm.com/

2. Run the command:

   % git clone git://git.openafs.org/openafs.git

   This will download the full repository and leave a checked-out tree in
   a subdirectory of the current directory named openafs. The repository
   itself is in the .git subdirectory of that directory.

   WARNING: The repository is approximately 60MiB currently and will only
   grow, so it may take some time to download the first time over a slow
   network connection.

3. Generate the additional required files:

   % cd openafs
   % ./regen.sh

The current development series is in the branch named master. The stable
releases are on separate branches named something like
openafs-stable_<version> with a separate branch for each major stable
release series. Use git branch -a to see a full list of branches.

OpenAFS uses the Gerrit code review system to review and merge all changes
to OpenAFS. More details are at:

    http://wiki.openafs.org/GitDevelopers/

including more detailed Git instructions.

It's by far preferred to use Gerrit to submit code changes, but if you
can't for whatever reason, you can instead open a bug and submit a patch
that way. Do this by sending mail to openafs-bugs@openafs.org with the
patch attached. But please use Gerrit if you can; patches sent in as bugs
will have to be forwarded to Gerrit by someone else, and it's easier for
everyone if you can enter them into Gerrit yourself.

Backport policy
------------
All patches should land on master first, unless the patch fixes a bug
that only exists in the stable branch.

Once a patch has been accepted into master, anyone can propose
backports to stable branches.

When cherry-picking a commit from another branch, please append a
"cherry picked from" section in your commit message. You'll also need
a separate Change-ID for Gerrit to recognize this as a separate
change. One workflow to do this:

1) Use "git cherry-pick -ex" to pick your commits onto another branch.
   The -x option will append the appropriate "cherry picked from"
   message, and the -e option will open your editor for you to edit
   the commit message.
2) In your editor, delete the existing Change-ID line. Save and quit.
3) Run "git commit --amend", saving and quitting again. Git will run
   the commit hook and generate a new Change-ID for Gerrit.

Warnings
========

OpenAFS Warning detection
-------------------------

There's been a concerted effort over the last few years, by many developers,
to reduce the number of warnings in the OpenAFS tree. In an attempt to
prevent warnings from creeping back in, we now have the ability to break the
build when new warnings appear.

This is only available for systems with gcc 4.2 or later or clang 3.2 or
later, and is disabled unless the --enable-checking option is supplied to
configure. Because we can't remove all of the warnings, we permit file by
file (and warning by warning) disabling of specific warnings. The
--enable-checking=all option prevents
this, and errors for any file containing a warning.

Disabling warnings
------------------

If warnings are unavoidable in a particular part of the build, they may be
disabled in an number of ways.

You can disable a single warning type in a particular file by using GCC
pragmas. If a warning can be disabled with a pragma, then the switch to use
will be listed in the error message you receive from the compiler. Pragmas
should be wrapped in IGNORE_SOME_GCC_WARNINGS, so that they aren't used
with non-gcc compilers, and can be disabled if desired. For example:
  #ifdef IGNORE_SOME_GCC_WARNINGS
  # pragma GCC diagnostic warning "-Wold-style-definition"
  #endif

It would appear that when built with -Werror, the llvm clang compiler will
still upgrade warnings that are suppresed in this way to errors. In this case,
the fix is to mark that warning as ignored, but only for clang. For example:
  #ifdef IGNORE_SOME_GCC_WARNINGS
  # ifdef __clang__
  #  pragma GCC diagnostic ignored "-Wdeprecated-declarations"
  # else
  #  pragma GCC diagnostic warning "-Wdeprecated-declarations"
  # endif
  #endif

If a pragma isn't available for your particular warning, you will need to
disable all warnings for the file in question. You can do this by supplying
the autoconf macro @CFLAGS_NOERROR@ in the build options for the file. For
example:
  lex.yy.o : lex.yy.c y.tab.c
         ${CC} -c ${CFLAGS} @CFLAGS_NOERROR@ lex.yy.c

If you add a new warning inhibition, please also add it to the list below.

Inhibited warnings
------------------

afs/afs_syscall.c    : old-style
		     : strict-proto
		     : all (ukernel) : syscall pointer issues
afsd/afsd_kernel.c   : deprecated    : daemon() marked as deprecated on Darwin
auth/ktc.c           : all (ukernel) : call_syscall doesn't have a prototype
bozo/bosserver.c     : deprecated    : daemon() marked as deprecated on Darwin
bucoord/ubik_db_if.c : strict-proto  : Ubik_Call
bucoord/commands.c   : all	     : Ubik_Call
				     : signed vs unsigned for dates
butc/tcudbprocs.c    : all	     : ubik_Call
external/heimdal/hcrypto/validate.c: all: statement with empty body
kauth/admin_tools.c  : strict-proto  : ubik_Call
kauth/authclient.c   : strict-proto  : ubik_Call nonsense
libadmin/kas/afs_kasAdmin.c: strict-proto : ubik_Call nonsense
libadmin/samples/rxstat_query_peer.c : all : util_RPCStatsStateGet types
libadmin/samples/rxstat_query_process.c : all : util_RPCStatsStateGet types
libadmin/test/client.c : all         : util_RPCStatsStateGet types
ubik/ubikclient.c    : strict-protos : ubik_Call
volser/vol-dump.c    : format        : afs_sfsize_t